Graham Greene famously designated the more pot-boiling entries in his oeuvre as "entertainments," a term the cinetrix applies with not a little glee to a certain stripe of workmanlike feature film. Not innovative, almost certainly cynically assembled, and yet...
It's whatever stylistic filigree or actorly filip that extends that ellipsis past "yet" that leaves the cinetrix not feeling like a punk for having spent her time watching.
Case in point: last night's entertainment, Runaway Jury. Now, Runaway Jury is a special case because it also belongs to its own singular category, which trumps genre, actors, even director. See, it's a Grishamovie, a term coined by the cinetrix's lost compadre Mark Olsen in Film Comment a few years back.
The "John Grisham films" pose several challenges to directorial authority. They demonstrate immense similarities with regards to structure, story, and character, even though Grisham himself does not receive screenwriting credit for any of them (although The Gingerbread Man is based on an apparently overhauled screenplay by Grisham). The bidding wars over his properties have certainly provided Grisham with the leverage to secure power of approval over the directors of his films. As with Stephen King, Grisham's authorial identification with these adaptations has grown so strong that the next-to-latest was officially titled John Grisham's The Rainmaker. On the other hand, the heavy reliance on starpower to fuel the Grisham vehicles not only suggests a lack of faith in their merits as pure storytelling, it may affect the balance of power: is The Firm a Tom Cruise film first and a Sydney Pollack film second?
To think of the Grisham cycle is to struggle to remember exactly which film a given scene or character comes from--the events and situations bleed together into some weird loop endlessly supplied with lawyers with accents and corporations and trials and chases. The template for the next Grisham franchise to pop up on the corner would be roughly this: young, earnest Southern lawyer, fresh out of law school, full of ideals and morals and good ole tenaciousness, tries to right some wrong. The bad guys always turn out to be not the government, the time-honored all-pervasive They (in fact, in The Pelican Brief, the CIA are made into guardian angels instead of weird spooks), but instead the new Them: Big Business. Rest assured that there is or has been a Big Cover-Up, after uncovering which the young lawyer finds BB's henchmen on his/her trail, experiences a dark night of the soul, and then a third act Big Trial/Big Chase where justice prevails. In the ideal Grisham formulation, the ending is an outlandishly unambiguous triumph of good guys over bad guys.
Mark wrote this piece well before
Jury saw the light of day, and its director,
Gary Fleder, is far from distinguished. But, but, but--this one gives a teensy bit more moral ambiguity than usual to its lead, the too smart for his own good juror #9, played by John Cusack. Also, a jury is an opportunity to assemble sterling ensemble players, in this case Luis Guzman, Nora Dunn [looking like
Kate Spade will if she spends a decade as a secret tippler], Jennifer Beals, Bill Nunn, and an actress playing a Goth girl named--wait for it--
Lydia Deets. [I know, I thought it was funny, too.]
You can't have a jury without scenery-chewing law talkers like Dustin Hoffman. And who vets the jurors during selection? Why, wily ol' Gene Hackman, that's who. Add devious jury-tampering eye candy Rachel Weisz as Cusack's love interest, toss in a colorful Nawlins settling, and, cher, you got yourself a meal.
Lest I forget, I think anyone writing about this film is contractually obligated to say that HOFFMAN AND HACKMAN ACT TOGETHER AT LAST. In a men's room. Big whoop. It's a far cry from either Midnight Cowboy or French Connection, sorry to say.
So, yeah, Runaway Jury tastes like cut-rate Soderbergh [which is to say souped-up Elmore Leonard]. What can you do? Sometimes circumstance reduces you to busting out a box of Zatarain rather than heading to Galatoire's, but a healthy dash of gumbo filé can hide a multitude of sins.