[Man, Craig Seligman's phone must be ringing off the hook today.]
In observation of Sontag's passing, a few film-specific excerpts from "Notes on Camp."
5. ....movie criticism (like lists of "The 10 Best Bad Movies I Have Seen") is
probably the greatest popularizer of Camp taste today, because most
people still go to the movies in a high-spirited and unpretentious way.
19. ....Genuine Camp -- for instance, the numbers devised for the Warner Brothers musicals of the early thirties (42nd Street; The Golddiggers of 1933; ... of 1935; ... of 1937; etc.) by Busby Berkeley -- does not mean to be funny.
20. Probably, intending to be campy is always harmful. The perfection of Trouble in Paradise and The Maltese Falcon,
among the greatest Camp movies ever made, comes from the effortless
smooth way in which tone is maintained. This is not so with such famous
would-be Camp films of the fifties as All About Eve and Beat the Devil.
These more recent movies have their fine moments, but the first is so
slick and the second so hysterical; they want so badly to be campy that
they're continually losing the beat. . . . Perhaps, though, it is not
so much a question of the unintended effect versus the conscious
intention, as of the delicate relation between parody and self-parody
in Camp. The films of Hitchcock are a showcase for this problem. When
self-parody lacks ebullience but instead reveals (even sporadically) a
contempt for one's themes and one's materials - as in To Catch a Thief, Rear Window, North by Northwest
-- the results are forced and heavy-handed, rarely Camp. Successful
Camp -- a movie like Carné's Drôle de Drame; the film performances of
Mae West and Edward Everett Horton; portions of the Goon Show -- even
when it reveals self-parody, reeks of self-love.
21. ...(Persons can even be induced to camp without their knowing it. Consider the way Fellini got Anita Ekberg to parody herself in La Dolce Vita.)
UPDATE: A big kiss for Carrie, who sent along this piece, which reveals that Sontag turned to Hollywood musicals of the '30s, 40s, and 50s while she was ill following a bone marrow transplant last summer.
It was a whole era she hadn't watched;
she was more interested in foreign films," said her close friend Sharon
DeLano, a writer and editor who visited often with Sontag over the last
months of her life.